After reading Michael King’s “Neighborhoods vs. Neighborhoods?” article, I’ve been thinking a bit about the reasons I joined FAN. First and foremost, I felt that FAN was a more representative, democratic body that is open to all residents of Austin neighborhoods. Nevertheless, there seems to be a good amount of FUD from the ANC side about what FAN is (see below), and I think we have an opportunity to clear that up. People have said that FAN is “anti-democratic”, yet I’ve recently learned of some undemocratic practices of ANC-affiliated NAs. For example: JHNA doesn’t allow renters to vote, and many other non-FAN NAs have membership fees as a requirement to vote. That is undemocratic, illustrating the difficulty of being both an advocacy/political organization and a representative body whose foremost goal is being the voice of the people. These groups have made their choice.
But I’d like to step back and consider our own membership requirements, specifically those stated at http://www.atxfriends.org/about/. We list a membership fee but later state that membership is currently free. Why not just strike that language altogether for now? Also, we ask the mandatory question "Will you champion the FAN vision at http://j.mp/FANVision?"
Is this strictly necessary? I always saw FAN not as an advocacy organization (although it does do that) but as a representative body which followed the will of its members. It seems to stand in conflict with the vision of “[encouraging] participation by the full diversity of neighborhood stakeholders”. It blunts any criticism of ANC for its recent rejection of DANA.
In any case, this is something to consider at the next board meeting.
FUD (fear, uncertainty, and doubt):
Chronicle publisher and Hyde Park resident Nick Barbaro suggests FoHP’s real agenda is defending commercial STRs, and that the “Friends” groups are “operating in support of those who ‘see Austin as a commodity, not a community.’ I think they’re master-planned for a specific agenda, I think they’re anti-democratic, deceptive, and, oh yes, wrong on the issues.”
Ingle didn’t stop there, saying she had “heard” that FAN is “funded by the Koch Brothers,” the fossil-fuel billionaires underwriting much national right-wing politics. Does she have any evidence for such an outlandish charge? “It’s a rumor that I’ve heard,” she said. “I’m just passing it along.” Nevertheless, she concluded, “I just wish people could get along a little better.”
NPCTs and the issue of fair representation: